Saturday, May 25, 2013
Are You a Careful Reader?
Reviewed by OFW editor: Carlos J Cortes
Published: August 28, 2012


Writers (I assume you’re one) are not ordinary readers. Most of us are too immersed in technique and the tricks and pitfalls of the trade to read without a part of our brain running on autopilot constantly analyzing the prose. I don’t know if our reading enjoyment is more or less, but we certainly read in a different mode.
 
As we read, we can’t help noticing POV slips—however slight—repetitions, continuity flaws or verbosity. Damn, I could have conveyed the same with half the words.
For your enjoyment I’ve selected a few fragments of prose, each devilishly difficult to pull off (this is a clue).
 
Read carefully to determine what makes each fragment unique. At the bottom of the page I’ve added a short explanation detailing the oddity of each excerpt. Don’t look! That would be cheating and we writers don’t do that. Do we?  
 
ONE
I was born at York on the first of March in the sixth year of the reign of King Charles the First. From the time when I was quite a young child, I had felt a great wish to spend my life at sea, and as I grew, so did this taste grow more and more strong; till at last I broke loose from my school and home, and found my way on foot to Hull, where I soon got a place on board a ship.

When we had set sail but a few days, a squall of wind came on, and on the fifth night we sprang a leak. All hands were sent to the pumps, but we felt the ship groan in all her planks, and her beams quake from stem to stern; so that it was soon quite clear there was no hope for her, and that all we could do was to save our lives.
 
TWO
If Youth, throughout all history, had had a champion to stand up for it; to show a doubting world that a child can think; and, possibly, do it practically, you wouldn't constantly run across folks today who claim that "a child don't know anything." A child's brain starts functioning at birth; and has, amongst its many infant convolutions, thousands of dormant atoms, into which God has put a mystic possibility for noticing an adult's act, and figuring out its purport.
 
Up to about its primary school days a child thinks, naturally, only of play. But many a form of play contains disciplinary factor. "You can't do this," or "that puts out out," shows a child that it must think, practically, or fail. Now, if, throughout childhood, a brain has no opposition, it is plain that it will attain a position of "status quo," as with our ordinary animals. Man knows not why a cow, dog, or lion was not born with a brain on a par with ours; why such animals cannot add, subtract, or obtain from books and schooling, that paramount position which Man Holds today.

But a human brain is not in that class. Constantly throbbing and pulsating, it rapidly forms opinions; attaining an ability of its own; a fact which is startlingly shown by an occasional child "prodigy" in music or school work. And as, with our dumb animals, a child's inability convincingly to impart its thoughts to us, should not class it as ignorant.
 
THREE
"Those women over there, probably mothers, bearers of ideas far too voluminous for their modest brains. And the man; a large dwarf or small giant—a young buck with a gelled mop with ideas almost certainly shorter than his hair".
 
FOUR
I sang, and thought I sang very well; but he just looked up into my face with a very quizzical expression.
 
I hope you read carefully and spotted what’s magical in each excerpt. Just in case you didn’t, here’s another passage written by Vince Auric and posted at Bigriddles. It contains clues about the technique used in some of the previous fragments.
 
This is an unusual paragraph. I'm curious how quickly you can find out what is so unusual about it. It looks so plain you would think nothing was wrong with it. In fact, nothing is wrong with it! It is unusual though. Study it, and think about it, but you still may not find anything odd. But if you work at it a bit, you might find out! Try to do so without any coaching! You probably won't, at first, find anything particularly odd or unusual or in any way dissimilar to any ordinary composition. That is not at all surprising, for it is no strain to accomplish in so short a paragraph a stunt similar to that which an author did throughout all of his book, without spoiling a good writing job, and it was no small book at that. By studying this paragraph assiduously, you will shortly, I trust, know what is its distinguishing oddity. Upon locating that "mark of distinction," you will probably doubt my story of this author and his book of similar unusuality throughout. It is commonly known among book-conscious folk and proof of it is still around. If you must know, this sort of writing is known as a lipogram, but don't look up that word in any dictionary until you find out what this is all about.
 
The answers?
 
ONE: The fragment is from Mary Godolphin’s Robinson Crusoe written in words of one syllable.
 
TWO: This one is from GADSBY A Story of Over 50,000 Words Without Using the Letter "E" by Ernest Vincent Wright Wetzel Publishing Co, Inc. Los Angeles, California [Chapter 1, p. 10-12, excerpts]
 
THREE:  The excerpt is from Michel Thaler's 233-page work, Le Train de Nulle Part (The Train from Nowhere). The novel contains lengthy passages of flowery prose, but not a lot of action. No verbs.
 
FOUR: This one is probably the hardest. It belongs to Lillie de Hegermann-Lindencrone's 1912 book In the Courts of Memory. The sentence contains all the letters in the alphabet.
 
If you spotted the oddity in the last excerpt by Auric, congratulations. If you didn’t, go stand in the corner and write “I will read carefully” one hundred times, and then try again.
 

Login/Register to leave a comment, or Login using or
Post Comments
No Comment Found.
    

 

Advertisement